Archive Page 4

02
Jun
11

Deliberate practice, motivation, and “The Dan Plan”

I’ve been paying a lot of attention recently to “The Dan Plan“. Anyone interested in getting better at anything should too.

Here’s how Dan describes his plan: “Through 10,000 hours of ‘deliberate practice,’ Dan, who currently has minimal golf experience, plans on becoming a professional golfer.” Becoming a professional golfer after getting to your 30’s without having taken up the game is ridiculously ambitious. However, deliberately practicing for 10,000 hours is just as ambitious, and Dan seems to be taking that in stride. Because of that, it’s worth thinking more deeply about the design of The Dan Plan. Continue reading ‘Deliberate practice, motivation, and “The Dan Plan”’

25
May
11

No More Tests

Spring has sprung, many schools have ended or are ending soon, and seniors are graduating into the real world and looking for jobs. In a few months, the nightly news will air a report on the difficulty some are having finding jobs and the mental strain that causes. Magazine and journalism shows will put together feature stories on the quarter-life crisis, the post-college malaise that many in their twenties feel as they search for meaningful existence in the “real world.” Analysts will blame the struggling economy, the ubiquitous internet, and coddling parents. Politicians will blame each other; twenty-somethings will blame themselves. But very few will focus on the real problem.

The real problem is that there are no more tests. Continue reading ‘No More Tests’

18
May
11

The hidden value of writing every day

Last fall, I began working with a student who was so committed to improving that she came in multiple times for for each paper she wrote. However, by late spring, she’d not improved much. Then something changed that made me think about how to approach these situations in the future.

I wanted to share her story here because it shows a truth about writing that often goes overlooked: if you want to get better at writing, practice, but if you want to get better at practicing writing,  write everyday.

Continue reading ‘The hidden value of writing every day’

06
May
11

What Mario knows that you don’t: Video games and assignment design

Back when video games came in cartridges and video stores existed, I rented a Nintendo game only to get home and find the instruction booklet was missing. Without that booklet, the game was unplayable. Random button mashing did not result in any productive action from my avatar, and I kept dying on the second screen.

Video games no longer require cartridges, and now it looks like they no longer require printed instruction manuals either. At least that’s the thought of Electronic Arts (EA), the gaming company responsible for many popular games, including the Madden football games. Last month, EA announced that they’d no longer include printed instruction manuals in video games. EA’s decision follows Ubisoft’s strategy who made the same decision to go manual-free last year.

While I’m sure that environmentalists will appreciate the trees that will be saved, this news should have more of an impact on teachers. What the video game industry has provided for us is a referendum on how our students acquire necessary skills and stay engaged in learning.

The lesson of EA and Ubisoft is that we could do a lot better. Continue reading ‘What Mario knows that you don’t: Video games and assignment design’

28
Apr
11

The Five-paragraph Fix: A new template

The other day, I asked groups of first-year students to identify the five biggest differences between high school writing and college writing. When they finished, I asked how many of the groups said something about leaving the five-paragraph essay behind. Nearly all of them. I asked why. One said, “We can’t just fill in the blanks and end up with a good essay.”

Then, I asked, “How many of you just wrote down the first five differences that came into your head?” All of them raised their hands.

That’s a problem.

Student’s are quick to figure out the limitations of the five-paragraph essay, but that’s not a fix. They still need to break the habit of just filling in the blanks and learn to exercise their critical thinking skills.

Let’s start that process off by giving them better blanks to fill. Continue reading ‘The Five-paragraph Fix: A new template’

23
Apr
11

Teacher profile: Joe Maddon

Baseball fans know Joe Maddon as the manager of the Tampa Bay Rays. Non-fans know him as the baseball coach in designer glasses in the Centrum Silver commercials. What most folks don’t know is that Joe Maddon is one of hell of a teacher.
That’s the conclusion I reached after reading Jonah Keri’s The Extra 2%, which recounts how management of the Tampa Bay Ray’s turned their team around after a decade of losing. While he is not the main focus of the book, the chapters on Maddon are easily the most intriguing from an educational standpoint. Keri portrays Maddon as an innovative thinker who is constantly looking for ways to get the best results out of his players.For this blog’s purposes, it’s worth mining Maddon’s philosophy for what it says about designing lessons and getting the most out of students. Continue reading ‘Teacher profile: Joe Maddon’
13
Apr
11

Is our children learning?

The other day I learned something fourteen years after I was taught it.

A student approached me to ask what I thought of an insight he made about the meaning of the color red in a novel. Essentially, he had said that the author was trying to tell us that a character was mad by putting that character into a red shirt. His professor didn’t buy his argument. He insisted he was right. He asked me who I thought was correct.

I asked the student how he knew that red meant anger. He said, “Well, red usually means anger.” So I asked him why valentines are red. He didn’t have an answer.

Then, we spoke about context how it helps aid interpretation. We talked about what kinds of things he would need to find in the novel for his statement to be correct. When I asked him if he felt he was more correct, he still believed he was, but he wanted to see if he could find the things we spoke about to prove it.

I don’t bring this story up to say anything about the way I taught this lesson. In fact, I’ve changed all of the details here except for the general premise. The true insight on my end came not from the situation but from what it helped me understand about a lesson I was once taught. Continue reading ‘Is our children learning?’

03
Apr
11

The Five-paragraph Fix: Why it’s needed.

A few days ago, my site stats showed that someone found my blog by searching for “how to write a non five paragraph essay.” Yesterday, someone came here after searching for “why is the five paragraph essay bad?” These searches evoked feelings of both satisfaction and guilt.  I was happy to see the gremlins who run such search engines would send those types of questions my way: those questions are why this blog exists. My guilt came from the fact that I’ve not yet covered this topic. However, given the fact that I did the same Google search and found it didn’t yield many successful results, I suppose it’s time to get on with it. So Anonymous Googlers, this one is for you.

Welcome to the first post in a series that I’m calling the “Five-Paragraph Fix.” To kick things off, let’s answer the second Googler’s question first. Why do we need a five-paragraph fix? Continue reading ‘The Five-paragraph Fix: Why it’s needed.’

27
Mar
11

Michael Scott: From caricature to character

Very soon, Steve Carrell will leave The Office, and the good folks at Dunder Mifflin won’t have Michael Scott to push around anymore. When that happens, television won’t just be losing one of its greatest characters. It will also lose one of the few who started off as a caricature and made the difficult transition to a character. That’s a sad thing became it will mean losing one of the few characters who we can laugh at and care about at the same time. It seems fitting then to take some time and look at how the writers on The Office pulled off that feat and to ask what writers might learn from it. Continue reading ‘Michael Scott: From caricature to character’

10
Mar
11

And another thing – A quick way to spot where a draft lacks flow

Most writing instructors want papers that flow, most writers want to write with flow, few concepts in writing are harder to define than flow. If pressed, I think many writing instructors might paraphrase Potter Stewart and note that they know it when they see it.  However, simply identifying that a draft doesn’t flow does little to help a writer understand why a paper doesn’t flow. That’s a harder task, one that deserves a lengthy explanation, and in the future, I hope to do that. Until then, here’s one quick way to spot places in a paper that don’t flow.

I teach students to look for three words, also, another, and additionally (and any other versions of these “adding” words).  These words mark the entrance of new ideas into a draft, and their presence often means that point is simply being appended without telling readers how and why this idea connects to the previous idea.

Once these points of disjuncture are spotted, incorporating them into the flow of the paper is fairly simple. Writers should ask themselves, “Why is this idea necessary?”, “Why this idea goes here?”, and “What does this idea add to the previous idea?” The answers to these questions should present the reader with a more thoroughly articulated claim that builds on the previous idea in the draft or locates a turning point of an argument. Revising the sentence to tell the reader how and why this idea needs to be added to the previous idea presents  the reader with the claim the writer is trying to make. Having a clear progression of claims is the first step to mastering flow.




Good Writer, Bad Writer

Good writer, bad writer reflects the philosophy behind the first writing lesson I attempt to teach students. Too many of them come into college believing that their writing abilities are set in stone. The bad writers continue to struggle, and the good writers don't take enough risks in their writing, figuring that any misstep will throw them back into the "bad writer" category.

Good writer, bad writer is my attempt to break the power of that dichotomy. On here, I share the lessons and attitudes that I teach, but I also talk about the attitudes I have towards my own writing since many of those have informed my own teaching. Thanks for visiting.

Most Visited Posts